How many times has a patient walked through your door, handed you her beautiful X-ray and asked you to make sense of it?
If you're like me and many others- I would hazard to guess that for years your use of X-rays has consisted of lifting those radiolucent films up to the overhead light, squinting your eyes a bit, then contorting your head left and then right, squinting some more. Then ultimately resigning yourself to asking the patient if they just so happened to also have the radiologist's radiology summary report.
Don't worry.
The problem is that many of us were never taught much regarding the reading of X-rays in school. But if we take the time to learn more about radiology, we can learn some of their impressive benefits in assisting with evaluation and treatment of our patients.
But, as a patient asked me just this week-
"Is there really any benefit to paying $100 for an X-ray?"
Well, specifically let's discuss her case-
The Advantages of Using Cervical X-rays for Orofacial Pain
My patient, [Ms. M] has presented with persistent constant daily retroorbital and temporal region headaches for roughly 10 years. She has visited a chiropractor, massage therapist and has had migraine injections on a regular basis throughout. She is an intensely driven small business owner and finds herself getting 4-5 hours of sleep a night and feeling like she's a failure if her health stops her from achieving her goals. Progress has been slow and she has significant upper cervical dysfunction.
I recently spoke to her about having open mouth A/P and lateral cephalometric X-rays taken. Her response wasn't totally unexpected-
"What exactly will cervical X-rays do for me?"
My response-
Specificity.
"Specificity" as it relates to orofacial manual therapy treatment has a number of advantages. Let's examine these:
1. AVOIDING ERRORS-
I certainly didn't say this to her, but I believe this reason is very important. As manual therapists we depend on our hands to feel for bony positioning and joint motion. It's one of our greatest skills. But it should come as no surprise that of the 5 senses, the sense we as human beings depend on most in life- is vision. There is power in seeing exactly how each vertebra is aligned and rotated. As we all know- each vertebra of the cervical spine can be flexed, extended, rotated left or right, side bent left or right, and even displaced and shifted forward or back. AND- also how much are each vertebra moved into these positions. Maybe you feel that a vertebra is stuck flexed forward, but its just the vertebra below extended backwards. In this way, we can look to confirm what our fingers are feeling to avoid errors. Although errors might be unlikely, the next two interrelated reasons are reason enough to request X-rays when progress is inconsistent-
2. ACCELERATING RECOVERY
3. IDENTIFYING THE UNEXPECTED
Maybe you didn't feel the instability of a vertebra when shifting forward. In a very dysfunctional spine there can be a number of multi segmental dysfunctions. Did you address one problem, only to miss another? If you did, perhaps the patient is getting better, but still not progressing as quickly as it could. The ability to accelerate the patient's recovery and to identify the unexpected are in my opinion the best reasons to recommend cervical X-rays.
4. FEEDBACK
How often do our patients require some reassurance? We all do. In those instances, it can be so helpful to a patient to see their problems/progress right before their eyes. Let's say a patient has been seen for 2 months- they feel better, but some of their symptoms still persist- occasional discomfort or stiffness. We've all seen patients that have pain, but have difficulty evaluating their own progress.
How often have we asked to see if a patient is improving- "What's your pain level on a scale of 0-10. And your patient answers with frustration- "I don't know- but it still hurts!"
Having the visual proof to show a patient their progress and reassure them there is improvement goes a long way towards having patient's "buy-in" to their progress. Let's face it, "fear" is often times a big obstacle for a patient to overcome in order for them to finally accept that they are feeling some relief and improvement. It never hurts to have visual proof to document your progress to the patient. Every veteran therapist knows how key patient "buy-in" is.
5. MARKETING
If you have before and after X-rays of your patient you will have a physician referral for life! Why? A picture is worth a thousand words!
But why not just have a radiologist read the X-ray?
Well, certainly because radiologists don't specialize in movement dysfunction! Yes, radiologists are concerned with diagnoses. Is there stenosis? Is there DJD? Maybe. But what does this tell us about the cause of those things? Obviously movement restrictions or hyper mobility will contribute to some of these problems- but maybe the problem hasn't advanced enough to see the degeneration yet. Maybe the cause of midcervical degeneration is a stuck AA joint a few levels above the problem. Unfortunately, a radiology report just won't share those intimate little details with us.
Also, the more we understand radiology the more we can assist the X-ray tech in his positioning and the choice of X-rays to be taken. Do we need the patient in perfect upright cervical postures if they spend 8 hours a day slumped in front of the computer and that is the only time that get their headaches? Does the patient only get their pain when in extended neck postures? Maybe then recommending a cervical extension stress X-ray would be most helpful. But only through your improved understanding of radiology is this possible.
So if you don't have knowledge about radiology, where can you go to learn more?
So if you think you're ready to nibble into the field of radiology and its potential impact into your manual therapy evaluation & treatment, here are 2 excellent resources-
1. Fundamentals of Musculoskeletal Imaging by Lynn N. McKinnis
I can't recommend this book enough. Very practical and user-friendly for the physical therapist. This is where I recommend anyone interested should turn. Highlights all the important areas on the subject looking at each individual area of treatment- TMJ, cervical, thoracic, lumbar, knee, etc.
2. St Augustine's course- Applied Musculoskeletal Imaging for Physical Therapists
I have not taken this particular course, but I have been instructed on the topic by a St Augustine instructor, Mark Strickland in Austin, TX. Very knowledgable, very practical information. I'd imagine this course is much the same.
So, have you personally found X-rays to be helpful in your manual therapy evaluation and treatment? If so, comment and let me know. I'm always interested in how many physical therapists utilize diagnostic imaging and if so, are there any ways that they particularly find them useful.
More on this in a future post regarding how to read upper cervical spine X-rays!